Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Brian Edmunds's avatar

A great podcast again.

Land taxes and wealth taxes are the latest version of ‘how to get more tax take’.

We know this because our government is constantly in a deficit.

Despite your disagreement to Gary Stevensons crusade for a wealth tax, his warning of an ever increasing disaster is a real one and should be considered.

We see every day mega wealth next to mega poor. From the favelas of Brazil to the Indian slums. From African famine to the American tent dwellers we see the poorest living cheek by jowl with the wealthiest on this planet.

Gary sees that if the rich keep getting richer then the result has to be the poor getting poorer. So I happen to think he has concerns that need to be heeded.

That said, your talk today, as informative as it was, missed the point.

Any tax has to be affordable. Not just to the poor but the wealthy too. Many people, normal people have accumulated wealth. But have no income to pay for taxation.

And this is where my own theory trumps all others. Because my view is that wealth is assets and goods bought with money that’s already been taxed. Or should have been!

I happen to believe that goods and assets are the accumulation of work. It’s the property of work and as such should not be taken or taxed. It’s theirs to sell as required. Their choice. Not to be forced to sell just to pay taxes.

However, money is a different thing. Money is not for keeping or it shouldn’t be. Money is your be fairly exchanged for the work and production of others. In a FULL and FAIR and complete exchange of work for work. It shouldn’t be held it must be exchanged in full in a time suitable for the needs of the rest and the needs of the government. That’s my firm belief.

Money is a token of our exchange. But it’s not being exchanged! It’s being held or rather withheld from the rest by the few. The few who hold it. The banks the wealth funds the pension funds the insurance funds indeed any fund or bank that holds our money for their use. The majority of us are made to be devoid of its use by withholding the natural course of money to be a full and fair exchange of work for work.

Once barriers or dams are placed in the way for free flowing money then you allow the slow or stagnant path of money. Causing the picture of our economic drought as we all see it now.

Money is the key to unlock flow by SPENDING.

So money has to be the answer to get more flow to ensure not just tax is paid but sufficient tax is supplied by supply sufficient glue fir us to increase our incomes to be in a position to pay more tax. You have to make us richer with money to afford increases in tax take.

So you have to look at certain consideration first. Firstly, is there sufficient money in the economy to begin with?

My view is it has to be calculated on need and population. We need enough to go around! It sounds simple but what is enough? Well it needs to be calculated on population amounts and needs of that population. So I have some sympathy with MMT that says we can produce more money. Yes! That’s not new it’s been the case since the beginning of money. We have produced amounts. So why not get the right amount?

I know there isn’t enough as our banks need to leverage money to give us more! My question is if banks do it for profit why can’t our treasury do it for nothing? Especially as more tax is needed as a result.

once that is argued we then turn to how do we get that money flowing? Well working and spending is the only way. We work and spend it all to give that flow its non stop feed. In the time we need, monthly.

Reward those more by all means. But unless the money is spent back we will always be short. We will always be devoid of its use. We will never be able to live without borrowing. We need full money turnover to get the economy for all.

The fairness comes in wealth. Goods and assets. That can be sold later. It’s fair! But the leveller is the necessity to spend money as it’s earned. That’s the leveller. Rich or poor you spend it. Hold assets not money. When assets turn back into money then it’s in play and can be taxed. While money glues sufficient taxes can be taken.

No posts

Ready for more?